Skip to content

LaGrange

At the place so selected

Published .

Something wrong? Submit a correction.

LaGrange County, Indiana, with Bloomfield and Lima townships highlighted
Bloomfield and Lima townships

No act of the Indiana legislature names LaGrange as the seat of justice of LaGrange County.


The legislature provided for the first one. The act forming the county, approved on the second of February, 1832, appointed five commissioners from other counties to fix the seat, and told the county's courts where to sit in the meantime:

Sec. 4. The circuit court and the board of county commissioners, when elected under the writ of election from the executive department, shall meet at the house of Moses Rice, and hold their first sessions, and adjourn to as near the centre of the county as a convenient place can be had, until the public buildings shall have been erected.

The act does not say where the commissioners would put it. The statute book said where it was by 1835. A road act approved on the seventh of February, 1835, runs from Lima, the seat of justice of Lagrange county.


The act that set out to move it was approved on the thirteenth of February, 1840. Its title is "An act to relocate the seat of justice in the county of La Grange."

It appointed five commissioners: John Jackson of Elkhart County, Joel Bristol of Noble, Albert Cole of Miami, and Marshall S. Wines and Thomas J. Lewis of Allen. None was from LaGrange. They were to meet at William McConnell's, in Eden Township, on the first Monday of May, and to relocate the seat

as near the centre thereof as the situation of the land and the interest of the county will admit, having due regard to the present, and probable future population of the county, and such donations as may be made for the benefit of said county of Lagrange.

Once they had chosen, section 4 had them certify the site to the county recorder, who shall make a proper record thereof. Section 5 had the county board appoint three men to see the public buildings put up. Section 7 says when the move would happen:

Sec. 7. So soon as the public buildings shall be completed, in the manner aforesaid, at the place so selected and designated, the same shall thereafter be the permanent seat of justice of the said county of Lagrange, and all courts of said county shall thereafter be holden at such new county seat; and until the erection and completion of such buildings, the circuit courts and all other courts shall be holden at Lima, or at any other place to which said courts may adjourn, in said county of Lagrange.

The act names no place. It sets out a way of choosing one, and a condition.


No act that followed names the place chosen. No act records the commissioners' certificate, and no act says when the buildings were finished. A road act of January 1844 runs to the county seat of Lagrange county and does not say which town that was.

What the legislature did pass, in January of 1844, was two short acts, on the twelfth and the thirteenth of January.

The first, approved on the twelfth:

That the board of commissioners of the county of Lagrage, be and they are hereby authorized to sell and convey the fee simple of the jail, court house, and public square, in the town of Lima, in such manner and upon such terms as said board may deem for the best interest of said county of Lagrange.

The second, approved on the thirteenth:

That the town plat of the town of Lagrange, in the county of Lagrange, laid off on the east half of the south-east quarter of section number nineteen, in township thirty-seven north, of range ten east, be and the same is hereby vacated.

Neither says why. The first does not say the seat had moved. The second does not mention the seat, a courthouse or a square. Battey's 1882 history puts the town of LaGrange in the south half of Section 19, platted on the eighteenth of June, 1836. No source read for this piece says whether the plat the act vacated is that plat, part of it, or another one.


Battey's 1882 county history tells the story the acts do not. On page 37, in Dr. J. H. Rerick's chapter, Battey says that once the middle and south of the county were settled, the location of the county seat became the dominant local question:

The question was carried into the Legislature, and, at first, Lima seemed to have the advantage; but, afterward seeing that the contention would be productive of much ill-feeling, and that the question would never be settled, even if temporarily gained for her side, Lima finally abandoned the strife, and the geographical center was harmoniously agreed upon for the county seat.

Battey names no act and no commissioners. On page 38 the history puts the spot on Fly Creek and says that Two land-owners, Joshua T. Hobbs and Reuben J. Dawson, were materially benefited by this creation of a new town, that they gave grounds for a public square, and that a building of two stories was erected in 1843 for the use of the public offices and court.

John Paul Jones's chapter on the town, on page 113, adds the builder and a day. Battey says the commissioners let the contract to Francis F. Jewett of Lima, that work began in 1842, and that Jewett completed it December 5, 1843. Then:

In 1844, the county officers having been removed from Lima, and the courts holding their sessions here, gave an impetus to the village and caused it to improve rapidly.

The completion date and the removal are Battey's. No act gives either.


The cornerstone of the present courthouse was laid on the fifteenth of August, 1878. Battey prints its inscriptions, and the east face reads, in part:

County Seat Located at Lima, A. D. 1832. Removed to La Grange, A. D. 1844.


The act of the twelfth of January, 1844 allowed the county board to sell the jail, court house and square at Lima. No act in the sessions through 1846 mentions them again, and none says whether they were sold.

Battey says, on page 140, that the proprietors of Lima had given the county eighty-four lots in consideration of having the county seat located there. On page 149 the history says that after the seat was removed, the court house was used for a schoolhouse, and for a hotel. On page 142, in 1882:

The old jail is yet standing on the southwest corner of the square.


So the move rests on an act that names no place, two acts of January 1844 that do not say why they were passed, a county history of 1882, and a stone. What is missing is an act naming LaGrange as the seat, the commissioners' certificate, and any record of when the buildings were completed. The 1840 act sent the certificate to the county recorder, who was to make a record of it. We have not read the recorder's records or the county commissioners' records. Four pages of the local laws of the 1839 and 1840 session, pages 147 to 150, are missing from the scan we read, and no other copy of that volume could be reached. The volume's own index lists four acts on those pages, about East Knightstown and Raysville, Shepherdstown, a road from New Albany to Vincennes and the board of Dubois County, but an index is not the act. Pages are also missing from five other volumes we read: pages 58 and 59 of the general laws of 1833 and 1834, 17 to 24 of the general laws of 1835 and 1836, 364 and 365 of the Revised Statutes of 1838, 140 and 141 of the local laws of 1843 and 1844, and 270 and 271 of the local laws of 1845 and 1846. What this piece says the acts do not contain is limited by those pages.

Battey prints the terms on which LaGrange's proprietors gave the county its square. It was to remain the county's

as long as the same shall be occupied as aforesaid, after which it shall revert to the original proprietors.

Sources

Every quotation in this piece was read off a page image, and none was taken from a scan's text layer. None needed a scanning correction, and no wording has been altered; "Lagrage" in the act of January 12, 1844 is as printed. The statement that no act names LaGrange as the seat covers the session laws of 1831-32 to 1845-46, read for every act naming LaGrange County or a place in it, except for pages missing from the scans: 1834 general pages 58 and 59, 1836 general 17 to 24, 1838 Revised Statutes 364 and 365, 1840 local 147 to 150, 1844 local 140 and 141, and 1846 local 270 and 271. No other copy of those volumes could be reached. The commissioners' records and the county recorder's records were not read.

What this rests on

Since publication

What this rests on

  1. Correction ·

    This piece said that no act of the legislature names LaGrange as the seat of justice, and that no later act mentions the Lima buildings, without saying that pages are missing from the scans it was read from: pages 147 to 150 of the 1839-40 local laws, and pages in five other volumes of the sessions it covers. No other copy of those volumes could be reached. The piece now names the missing pages and says that its statements about what the acts do not contain are limited by them. The source note says the same.

More from LaGrange

LaGrange

Fourteen streets and not one of their own

Four men platted this county's seat in June 1836 and named fourteen streets. Not one of the fourteen carries a name of the four. The surnames that did reach the map arrived thirty years later, through additions their owners laid out themselves.

Support the Gazette

Nothing on this site is behind a paywall and nothing on it is sponsored. If it has been worth something to you, there are three ways to give something back, and only one of them involves money.

Support the Gazette