Skip to content

LaGrange County

Burned with the Hancock county Library

Published .

Something wrong? Submit a correction.

In January of 1842 the Indiana legislature took up the matter of four books belonging to LaGrange County. It did not pass an act. It passed a joint resolution, printed fourth among the session's joint resolutions, and this is the whole of it:

WHEREAS, Sometime in the year 1839, the Probate Judge of Lagrange county removed from said county, carrying with him one copy of the first, one copy of the second, one copy of the third, and one copy of the fourth volumes of Blackford's Reports, intended for the use of the Probate Judge of said county: And whereas, the Probate Judge of said county is destitute of the above named authorities: And whereas, it appears that the above named volumes of said reports were burned with the Hancock county Library; Therefore,

Be it resolved by the General Assembly of the State of Indiana, That the Secretary of State be, and he is hereby authorized and required to forward the said volumes to said counties at the time he forwards the laws of the present session, out of any number of said reports which may be in the State Library, for further distribution.

It was approved on the twelfth of January, 1842. Its title is "A Joint Resolution Relative to Blackford's Reports in Lagrange and Hancock counties."


The journals the House and the Senate kept of that session record how it got through. It began in the House as joint resolution No. 14. Where it was introduced, and on whose petition, is not in anything read for this piece. Two pages of the House journal, 82 and 83, are missing from the only scan that could be reached.

On page 86 of the House journal it was read a second time and ordered to be engrossed, under a title naming one county:

No. 14—In relation to Blackford's reports in Lagrange county;

On page 132 it was read a third time, and lost:

No. 14—A joint resolution relative to Blackford's Reports in La-grange county;

Read a third time, and on the question, Shall the bill pass? was decided in the negative.

On page 177 the House went back to it:

Mr. Brown of M., moved to reconsider the vote on the passage of bill No. 14, in relation to Blackford's reports in Lagrange county;

Which prevailed.

And then bill was referred to a select committee, with instructions to supply that county with four copies of Blackford's reports;

And Messrs. Thompson of N. and L., Brown of M., and Foulk, were appointed said committee.

The journal's list of members, on page 4, gives the counties of Noble and Lagrange one member, John Thompson, and names one Brown from a county beginning with M, William J. Brown of Marion.

On page 213 the committee reported:

Mr. Thompson of N. and L., from a select committee, reported back joint resolution relative to Blackford's Reports, &c., with amendments;

Which were concurred in.

And then said joint resolution passed.

The House's message carrying it to the Senate, on page 236 of the Senate journal, gives it a different title:

No. 14—a joint resolution relative to Blackford's reports in La-grange and Hancock counties.

The Senate read it a second time on page 299 of its journal and took it up on its third reading on page 309. On page 334 of the House journal the Senate reports that it has passed the resolution under that title, All without amendment.

Hancock County appears in the title only after the select committee's amendments. The three House entries before the committee reported name Lagrange county alone, and the committee was instructed to supply "that county" with four copies. The journal does not print the amendments, and nothing in either journal that we read says why Hancock was added. Neither names the judge or says when the library burned.

The resolution does not name the judge.

Battey's 1882 history lists the county's officers so far as we can trace, and its list of probate judges is one line:

Probate Judges.—Elias B. Smith and William S. Prentiss.

It gives no years for either. The same two names appear on page 35, again without dates.

Both names are in the session laws of the period. An act of the seventeenth of February, 1838, incorporating the Michigan and Indiana Rail Road Company, names an Elias B. Smith among twelve men of Lagrange county. The act of the thirteenth of January, 1845, incorporating the Lagrange Phalanx, names two men, and one of them is W. S. Prentiss.

Nothing read for this piece identifies either man as the probate judge who left the county in 1839.


The resolution says what he took and when he went: one copy each of the first four volumes of Blackford's Reports, Sometime in the year 1839. It does not say where he went. It does not say he went to Hancock County. It says the books burned with the Hancock County library, and it leaves the road between the two unexplained.

The resolution ordered the Secretary of State to send the four volumes to both counties, out of the State Library's stock.

We have not found anything saying whether he did. No later act or resolution through 1846 mentions the county's copies, and a search of the scanned text of Battey's 1882 history, the 1893 county atlas and Ford's 1920 history finds no mention of the loss. Who the judge was, how the books got to Hancock County, and when its library burned are not established by anything we have read.

Hancock County did have a library to burn. George J. Richman's 1916 history of Hancock County quotes the county's organizing act as setting aside a tenth of the proceeds of lot sales at the county seat for one, and LaGrange County's own act of 1832 has the same provision. Richman tells what became of the library, and does not give the year of the fire. What it prints is the last report of the county librarian, W. R. West, made in December of 1851:

I found it consisted of the scattered fragments of books saved from the fire at the time the library was burned and those remaining being only parts of works and even them so injured by fire that they are nearly entirely valueless

West paid the county treasurer twenty dollars for the books he had received, and resigned.

Sources

Every quotation in this piece was read off a page image. None needed a scanning correction, and no wording has been altered. The searches for Blackford's Reports in the 1882 county history, the 1893 atlas, Ford's 1920 history and the session laws of 1831-32 to 1845-46, and for a library fire in Binford's 1882 history of Hancock County, were searches of each book's scanned text, not a reading of every page. So was the search of the House and Senate journals of 1841-42, which found the pages quoted here; those pages, and pages 72 to 81 of the House journal, were then read off the page images. Pages 82 and 83 of the House journal are missing from the only scan we could reach, and the journals' indexes were not read.

What this rests on

Since publication

What this rests on

  1. Correction ·

    This piece now adds the resolution's passage through the House and the Senate as the journals of the session record it, read off the page images: its second and third readings under a title naming LaGrange County alone, the vote against it, the reconsideration and select committee, the passage with the committee's amendments, and the title naming both counties under which the Senate took it up. It says that Hancock County appears in the title only after the committee's amendments. Neither journal, on the pages read, names the judge or dates the fire.

More from LaGrange County

Eden Township

A hole in the roof and the rest was the hearth

The first schools in this county were log rooms with slabs for desks and no chimney. The teachers were paid ten dollars a month or ten shillings a week, and one paid for her board in corn, two bushels a week.

Support the Gazette

Nothing on this site is behind a paywall and nothing on it is sponsored. If it has been worth something to you, there are three ways to give something back, and only one of them involves money.

Support the Gazette