Skip to content

LaGrange County

Four jurors from any one civil township

Published .

Something wrong? Submit a correction.

An act of six sections approved on the fifteenth of January, 1844, is headed An Act to provide for summoning petit jurors in the Lagrange circuit and probate courts. Its first section:

Section 1. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Indiana, That hereafter petit jurors shall be selected and summoned to serve as such in the Lagrange circuit and probate courts in the following manner, to-wit: Whenever there may be an issue joined between parties in said courts, the sheriff shall, by order of the court, summon twelve reputable freeholders or householders of said county having the qualification of jurors according to the existing laws of this state.


The state's own law was different. The Revised Statutes of 1843 had the county commissioners, once a year at their May session, put the names of qualified persons into a box:

Sect. 3. Such board of county commissioners, at their May session annually, shall cause a number of names of qualified persons, equal to the aggregate number of grand and petit jurors required for the several terms of the circuit court of such county for the ensuing year, to be written on separate pieces of paper and put into a a box provided for that purpose.

The clerk of the circuit court then drew twelve names for each week of each term, in the board's presence, and those twelve were the petit jury for that week. The jurors had to be good reputable freeholders or householders, resident of the county in which they are selected and taxable therein. The sheriff summoned a jury himself when there was none, or when the week's panel had run out, and then each party had six peremptory challenges instead of three. Three was the general rule: in any court of record each party had the right of peremptory challenge to three jurors.

The act for LaGrange County put the choice of petit jurors with the sheriff instead, twelve whenever there was an issue joined between parties, on the court's order, and its second section set the terms:

Sec. 2. The said sheriff in summoning jurors under the provisions of this act, shall not summon exceeding four jurors from any one civil township, without the consent of both parties, and either party shall have a right to challenge peremptorily five jurors.

Anyone summoned who did not come faced the penalty already in law for delinquent jurors. The clerk was to tax a jury fee in all cases of six dollars against the party losing the case, with seventy-five cents to the sheriff for each panel, and the county board was to pay each juror a dollar a day.

The state's jury chapter, read whole for this piece, sets no rate of pay. Its sixteenth section gives jurors summoned by the sheriff the compensation of the regular panel without saying what that was, and a search of the volume's scanned text, its index included, turned up no figure elsewhere. So whether a dollar a day was more, less or the same, the Revised Statutes as read for this piece do not show.

The act names no one and gives no reason.


LaGrange was not alone in it. The Revised Statutes of 1843 had left such laws standing, among the acts that continue in force:

  1. All acts and parts of acts allowing or providing any particular mode of summoning grand and petit jurors in the counties therein named.

In the same session, and in the same volume, three more counties got jury laws of their own. Blackford's, approved on the thirteenth of January, had the sheriff pick twelve jurors for each case. Lawrence's, approved the same day as LaGrange's, had the county board name fifteen householders for each term. Decatur and Warren's, also approved that day, had the sheriff pick twelve for each case and gave each party eight peremptory challenges where the right of peremptory challenge has heretofore been limited to three jurors. None of the three, each read whole, limits how many jurors may come from one township, and none puts a jury fee on the party that lost.

A search of the scanned text of every session volume held, from 1832 to 1849, finds county jury acts by their titles in most sessions, for counties from Parke and Spencer to Porter and Jackson. Only the three above were read in full for this piece. The same search finds no later act that names the LaGrange law, to repeal it, extend it or make it general, and the two county histories, searched the same way, do not mention it.

It is a law about summoning petit jurors, and it ends by fixing the pay of the grand jurors as well. The fifth section adds and also one dollar per day to the grand jurors of said circuit court.

Sources

Every quotation in this piece was read off a page image, and none was taken from a scan's text layer. No wording has been altered, and line-end hyphens are joined. The act was found through this archive's reading of the session laws of 1831-32 to 1845-46 for LaGrange County. The other county jury acts were found by their titles in the scanned text of every session volume held from 1831-32 to 1848-49; three were read in full and the rest were not. That no later act names this one rests on the same search, not on reading those volumes page by page. The two county histories were searched in their scanned text for juries and jurors and were not read whole.

What this rests on

More from LaGrange County

Eden Township

A hole in the roof and the rest was the hearth

The first schools in this county were log rooms with slabs for desks and no chimney. The teachers were paid ten dollars a month or ten shillings a week, and one paid for her board in corn, two bushels a week.

Support the Gazette

Nothing on this site is behind a paywall and nothing on it is sponsored. If it has been worth something to you, there are three ways to give something back, and only one of them involves money.

Support the Gazette