Skip to content

LaGrange County

A movable institution

Published .

Something wrong? Submit a correction.

The law that decided who could choose a new county's seat of justice was approved on the fourteenth of January, 1824, under the title "An Act to establish Seats of Justice in New Counties." Its first section begins with the men:

Sec. 1. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the state of Indiana, That whenever any new county shall be laid off, five commissioners shall be appointed, who, at the time of discharging the duties herein enjoined, neither reside in such new county, nor hold any real estate therein.

It was reprinted in the revisions of 1831, 1838 and 1843. It is chapter LXXXV of the Revised Laws of 1831, on page 459, and chapter XCIII of the Revised Statutes of 1838, on page 505, in the same words. In the Revised Statutes of 1843 it is section 1 of chapter 18, on page 349, with the general assembly written in as the body that appoints, and the printer's note in the margin reads Five commissioners to be appointed—qualifications. The only amendment read for this piece, of January 1842, set the commissioners' pay at two dollars a day and two dollars for every twenty-five miles travelled.

The same section goes on. The five were to fix the seat

taking into view the extent thereof, the quality of the land, and the prospect of future, as well as the weight of present population, together with the probability of future divisions; and it shall be the further duty of the said commissioners to receive donations in land, from any person or persons owning lands in such county, and offering donations for the use of the same

The men who chose could neither live in the county nor own land in it. The men who offered land to be chosen were, in the act's words, persons owning lands in such county.


The acts this archive has read for LaGrange, Elkhart and Noble counties name fourteen commissions to fix or move a county seat between 1832 and 1846. These are their members, with the counties the acts give them.

  1. LaGrange, 1832. Lewis G. Thompson and Francis Comporit of Allen, N. B. Griffith of St. Joseph, Peter Noland of Delaware, William Watt of Union.
  2. Huntington, 1834. Philip Moore of Delaware, Joseph Holman of Miami, David Rankin of Allen, Daniel R. Bearss of Elkhart, Benjamin Berry of Grant.
  3. Marshall, 1836. Hiram Wheeler and Griffin Treadway of Laporte, Samuel C. Sample and Peter Johnson of St. Joseph, John Rohrer of Elkhart.
  4. Noble, 1836. Albert Powell of Lagrange, John Carpenter and Eli Penwell of Elkhart, Rufus M'Donald of Allen, George A. Fate of Huntington.
  5. Kosciusko, 1836. James Cook, Ebenezer Brown and Israel De Camp of Elkhart, Isaac Eaton of St. Joseph, Marinus Willet of Rush.
  6. Lake, 1837. John Sailor of Porter, John B. Niles of Laporte, Israel Rush of St. Joseph, John Newell of Elkhart, William Allen of Laporte.
  7. Steuben, 1837. John W. Vileot of Elkhart, Henry Hosteller, sen., of Noble, Isaac Eaton of St. Joseph, Benjamin Jones of Lagrange, John M'Intosh of Allen.
  8. De Kalb, 1837. Edward Littlefield of Lagrange, Cornelius Gilmore of Steuben, Samuel Dibble of Elkhart, James Latta of Noble, Robert Work of Allen.
  9. Wells, 1837. John D. Defrees of Elkhart, Peter Johnson of Saint Joseph, Francis De Lasselle, jr., of Allen, David McNight of Adams, William Widup of Wayne.
  10. Noble, 1837, to re-locate. Oliver Crane of Elkhart, Levi L. Todd of Johnson, Green T. Simpson of Henry, William Allen of Laporte, John E. Hill of Allen, Samuel T. Clark of Tippecanoe.
  11. Lake, 1839. Asahel K. Paine of Porter, Stephen Jones and John M. Lemon of Laporte, Samuel Witter of St. Joseph, Jacob Ellis of Elkhart.
  12. Whitley, 1839, to relocate. Samuel Edsall and A. L. Ballard of Allen, John K. Evans of Adams, Isaac Covert of Wells, John Jackson of Elkhart.
  13. LaGrange, 1840, to relocate. John Jackson of Elkhart, Joel Bristol of Noble, Albert Cole of Miami, Marshall S. Wines and Thomas J. Lewis of Allen.
  14. Noble, 1844, to relocate. Lot Day and Charles M. Heaton of St. Joseph, John Jackson and Allan Tibbetts of Elkhart, Ephraim Seley of Lagrange, Enos Beall of Steuben.

Not one of the seventy-two is stated to be of the county he was sent to.

These acts name their authority loosely. Boone County's of 1832, which is not among the fourteen, appoints its commissioners under the Act to fix the seats of justice in new counties and dates it the fourteenth of January, 1824, the date of the act quoted above. LaGrange's of 1832 and Huntington's of 1834 cite a title close to that one, an act fixing the seat or seats of justice "in all new counties hereafter to be laid off", and give no date. An act printed in the Revised Laws of 1824, approved on the seventeenth of December, 1823, before the 1824 act was, cites a title nearly the same, so a title of that shape did not belong to the 1824 act alone. Lake's of 1837 names no authority at all. Which act appointed the men who chose LaGrange County's seat, this piece does not establish.

LaGrange sent its men out and took other counties' men in. Albert Powell of LaGrange is the first name on Noble's commission of 1836, and Ephraim Seley of LaGrange is on Noble's of 1844. Benjamin Jones went to Steuben and Edward Littlefield to De Kalb. When LaGrange's own seat was put to commissioners in 1840, they included Joel Bristol of Noble and John Jackson of Elkhart, whose commission this archive has written about. The acts for Noble, Steuben and De Kalb each made it the duty of the sheriff of LaGrange County to tell their commissioners they had been appointed.

A John Jackson of Elkhart is on three of the four commissions sent to move a seat, Whitley's, LaGrange's and Noble's. The acts do not say he was one man.


The rule is written for a new county. Four of the fourteen commissions were sent to move a seat that a county already had, and the acts sending them do not treat the 1824 act alike.

The act for Whitley County, approved on the eighteenth of February, 1839, takes all of it:

Said commissioners to be governed in all respects by the provisions of an act of the General Assembly of the State of Indiana, entitled, "an act to establish seats of justice in new counties," approved, January 14, 1824.

It does not say whether a rule about living in a new county reached a county that was not new.

The other three, Noble's of 1837, LaGrange's of 1840 and Noble's of 1844, take only its pay. Each has a sixth section in nearly the same words, that the commissioners shall receive the same compensation and be paid in the same manner, as is provided for in an act entitled "an act to establish seats of justice in new counties," approved January 14, 1824. What the law required of the men who moved those three seats, the acts do not say, and this piece does not say either.


Noble County's seat was put to commissioners three times and to the voters once.

The act organizing the county, approved on the sixth of February, 1836, sent the five men of 1836 to fix its permanent seat, to convene at the house of Adam Engle. The printer set the title as "AN ACT to organize the county of Nobls." An act approved on the fourth of February, 1837 sent six more to re-locate it, meeting at Wolf Lake, at the house of P. C. Miller. Its seventh section is, nearly word for word, the one LaGrange's act would carry three years later: the seat would be permanent So soon as the public buildings shall be completed in manner aforesaid at the place so selected and designated.

The acts name a seat twice. A road act approved on the seventeenth of February, 1838 runs from Logansport in Cass county to Augusta the county seat of Noble county, and its section 26 sent three men of LaGrange, Peter Lampson, Wm. Dickerson and George Wallcott, to lay a road from the county seat of Noble county, to Ontario, in Lagrange county, from thence to Lima. A road act of the thirteenth of February, 1843 runs the nearest and best way to Augusta, the county seat of Noble county.

On the twenty-fifth of March, 1843, by the preamble of an act passed the next January, a portion of the records of the public offices, in Noble county, were destroyed by fire. The act names the losses in the Clerk's, the Auditor's and the Treasurer's offices. It names no building.

The third commission, of the thirteenth of January, 1844, was to meet at Augusta and relocate the seat at Augusta, or any other place as near the centre thereof as the situation of the land and the interest of the county will admit. The next act sent no commissioners. Approved on the tenth of January, 1846, it had the voters write on their tickets the place they wanted, in as many as three rounds, until one place had a majority. It names no place. Its last section ordered it printed in the "Goshen Democrat," and the "Lagrange County Democrat," at Noble County's expense.

No act read for this piece names Albion, through the session of 1848 and 1849.


Battey's 1882 county history, in its Noble County half, tells the rest, and it tells some of it twice in different ways.

Its county chapter puts the first seat at Sparta. On page 41 it prints the 1836 commissioners' report, dated at Noble on the third of May, 1836, fixing the seat in Sparta Township on land of Isaac Spencer and Reuben Jackson Dawson, and says that No public buildings were ever erected at Sparta. Its Sparta Township chapter agrees, on page 236. Weston A. Goodspeed's chapter on York Township, in the same volume, opens differently:

The seat of justice was first established at Augusta, a "defunct" town of modest pretensions, situated on Section 15.

That is one book disagreeing with itself. It is not two sources disagreeing, and nothing in either chapter settles it.

Battey says the 1837 commissioners chose Augusta, where a court house and jail were built; that the court house burned early in the year of 1843; that the 1844 commissioners met at Augusta and

drove the stake and permanently located the seat of justice at Port Mitchell.

and that at the votes of 1846 the friends of Augusta, left out by two votes in June, went over to the " Center," as Albion was then called, which won. No act names Sparta, Port Mitchell or Albion as the seat. One act, of the nineteenth of January, 1846, lays out a road commencing at the court house in Port Mitchell in Noble county.

Where Battey and the acts disagree, both are given here and neither is preferred.

  • The 1836 commission. The act, approved in February, names five. Battey says three were appointed At the session of the Legislature in March, 1836, George A. Fate, R. McDonald and Eli Penwell, and the report it prints is signed by those three. Albert Powell and John Carpenter are not in Battey's account.
  • The 1837 commission. The act has Levi L. Todd of Johnson County and Samuel T. Clark of Tippecanoe. Battey has Todd of Cass and Samuel F. Clark of Miami.
  • The 1844 commission. The act was approved on the thirteenth of January; Battey says it passed on the fourteenth. The act names six; Battey names five and leaves out Enos Beall of Steuben. The act prints Charles M. Heaton, Ephraim Seley and Allan Tibbetts; Battey prints Charles W. Heaton, Ephraim Seeley and Allen Tibbitts.
  • The fire. The act gives the twenty-fifth of March, 1843, and records burned in three offices, and names no building. Battey gives the court house, early in 1843.
  • LaGrange and the Noble country. The act forming LaGrange in 1832 attached the territory south of it to the said county of Lagrange for civil and judicial purposes. Battey says Noble was a part of La Grange and that the present county of Noble being included in the new county.
The act's Ephraim Seley of Lagrange county is Ephraim Seeley in Battey. Whether he is the Ephraim Seeley this archive has followed through the board of justices and the Mongoquinong post office, we have not established, and this piece does not say he is. Pages are missing from six of the volumes these readings rest on: pages 58 and 59 of the general laws of 1833 and 1834, 17 to 24 of the general laws of 1835 and 1836, 364 and 365 of the Revised Statutes of 1838, 147 to 150 of the local laws of 1839 and 1840, 140 and 141 of the local laws of 1843 and 1844, which fall inside the act on Noble's burned records, and 270 and 271 of the local laws of 1845 and 1846. What this piece says the acts do not contain is limited by those pages.

Battey's own summing up of Noble's seat, on page 42:

The seat of justice was a movable institution and neither a permanent location nor driving the stake could hold it.

Sources

Every quotation in this piece was read off a page image, and none was taken from a scan's text layer. No wording has been altered, and line-end hyphens in the acts are joined. Nobls in the 1836 act's title, Seley, Comporit, Vileot and Allan Tibbetts are as the acts print them. The fourteen commissions are every county seat commission in this archive's readings of the session laws of 1831-32 to 1845-46 for LaGrange, Elkhart and Noble counties, and only those: a commission for another county that names none of the three is not among them. Those readings cover the acts naming the three counties except for pages missing from the scans: 1834 general pages 58 and 59, 1836 general 17 to 24, 1838 Revised Statutes 364 and 365, 1840 local 147 to 150, 1844 local 140 and 141, and 1846 local 270 and 271. For 1846-47 to 1848-49 the volumes' text layers were searched and not read page by page. An amendment to the 1824 act approved December 19, 1825, named in the 1831 Revised Laws and in an 1832 act for Boone County, was not read; section 1 appears unchanged in the 1831, 1838 and 1843 revisions. The county commissioners' and recorder's records of Noble County were not read. Both county halves of the 1882 volume are the work of one compiler; this piece cites only the Noble County half.

What this rests on

More from LaGrange County

Eden Township

A hole in the roof and the rest was the hearth

The first schools in this county were log rooms with slabs for desks and no chimney. The teachers were paid ten dollars a month or ten shillings a week, and one paid for her board in corn, two bushels a week.

Support the Gazette

Nothing on this site is behind a paywall and nothing on it is sponsored. If it has been worth something to you, there are three ways to give something back, and only one of them involves money.

Support the Gazette